Skip to main content

What Leibniz taught me....

There is a way to talk and think about God that should not make anyone feel uncomfortable....a philosophical method that encourages open discussion... There is a way to ask questions (hypothetical inquiries) about the divine attributes and the divine nature, to investigate our "ideas" of God and what we are in fact saying when we posit "God's existence" ... One can delve into such matters without feeling obliged to arrive at hastily-conceived answers to specific questions...There is affirm possibilities and probabilities without landing upon anything definite....There is a way to recognize, problems, puzzles, contradictions involving God...There is a way to admit ignorance and uncertainty about the ultimate reality without anyone turning into a dogmatic atheist....There is a way to avoid false claims and misconceptions about God...Attacking such misconceptions does not make one an atheist - but rather helps to defeat superstition and idolatry (two of the misshapen poster-childs of false religion)...There is a way to humbly and painstakingly search for and seek out an elusive Truth - that is beyond the reach of language...The appreciation of the difficulty is in itself far more satisfying than having to accept tired formulas... It is better at times to suspend our judgment, to gather evidence, to keep the discussion open, to maximize the possible scenarios....Rationality is the enemy of "religiosity" but perhaps in the end the friend of true religion...  Leibniz's great insight: Leibniz sought a way of speaking about God that had a basis in logic and experience....By grounding his discussion of God in logic, he allowed for a calm, open-ended inquiry to take place - without bickering over Scriptural controversies... Leibniz sought to make "God's justice" (theo-dicy) palatable for a modern audience; by doing so, he sought to show that God's justice was akin to earthly modes of justice - that the obligations (toward goodness and charity) impinging upon the Almighty were the same moral imperatives impinging upon us...as such he saw the need to combat the understanding of God as being "unrestrained" by any external principles of right. For Leibniz, the only possible God is one who "acts like God" - an intelligence  amenable to the limitations imposed by logical necessity, a Being who exhibits perfect justice, goodness, mercy, knowledge - while respecting the checks that these may place on his power...God cannot act against the Good, the True or the Just because to do so would undermine His divine standing as God. Or to say it another way: God is good first and powerful second. An all-powerful deity who acts "indifferently" - "arbitrarily" or "maliciously" without respect for eternal norms is a contradiction in terms. Imagine a universe where God chose randomly and erratically throughout the course of time....What sort of coherence would attach to the worship of pure will? One can imagine an evil, erratic genius,  perhaps, but not as a being to be worshipped...The idea of God is therefore incompatible with any whimsical, arbitrary, malicious, vindictive or tyrannical tendencies ...Leibniz' rationalist conclusion is akin to Plato's Euthyphro: Things do not become good and right because of God choosing them to be so...rather, God chooses them because they are good and just ....




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

1974

Prologue - > We are fortunate to live in a time, or so it is said, when we of the future no longer feel the burden of gender to such a degree as in previous ages; nowadays there is no pre-established norm or "role" for us to perform or hold onto like a chain about the neck. There was a time, of course, and not so long ago, when men were de facto expected to be  tough strong, resilient, athletic, assertive... and which to judge by the role models in movies and popular culture which we could add on silent, stoical, protective, while no great shock was registered if there should be a woman or more than one who in some degree was known (also through popular culture, movies, novels, songs, etc. in comparison with her male counterparts) as:  soft, demure,  flirtatious, sociable, wise,  and to which one might add on: practical, prescient, intuitive, gregarious, solicitous, nurturing and perhaps multi-tasking,  socially-aware, loyal, resilient .   With regard to the males, unfair
Post a Comment
Read more

The "Endless Summer" Feeling a.k.a. "Time Stop Mechanism"

Growing up out west - we had what was known as the "endless summer" feeling - a moment in the summer when - not Time per se - but hectic, anxious, nerve-wracking time would come to a standstill. Change would still happen of course, things would continue moving, interacting, but at a slower, more predictable pace...the rhythms of summer would take over with sunny days giving way to balmy nights...a certain degree of repetition would lend structure to this seeming "pause" in the action...Clouds still move across the sky, waves still crash against the shore, traffic on the roads, people walking, biking, swimming - but all in a self-contained world over which one had some semblance of control..Long days at the beach, lying in the sun or playing tennis at the community college, watching the heat rise on the pavement, shooting baskets on the outdoor courts, sitting poolside at a neighbor's house, sitting on the lawn at dusk, staying outside on summer nights with no wi
Post a Comment
Read more

Historicity - Facticity - Thrownness - Temporality - Historical Fate

  Historicity...Facticity...Thrownness... Temporality...Geworfenheit...the condition of having been born into a situation, thrown into a particular place and time - having one's Life conditioned by these unique, random, haphazard, non-repeating individual factors...Born into this year - this decade - the 1960s for example...growing up (for the most part) in this other decade (the 1970s) in a particular location, California, the west coast, in a particular milieu, the suburbs, with a stable family, on a quiet street (a former orange and walnut grove), with enough water and rain (or so we thought), on the edge of the desert, east of Los Angeles, a valley surrounded by mountains, a sleepy agricultural town with a college or two, during an uncrowded era of fast-moving freeways, a corner enclave of ranch homes, uphill from a dairy,  a familiar mountain, a horse farm and a dried out river bed, in a neighborhood full of kids on bikes and roller skates, during such and such a time, a postw
Post a Comment
Read more